The first presentations went really well i thought. I thought both groups were very creative in their presentations, although i must admit that the new criticism group might have slightly stole some of my group's thunder since there are some similarities. For this reason I feel I must make it clear that any similarities are purely coincidental and that the script for our presentation was completely written before they presented. Great minds think alike.
I do not like New Criticism. It might be because I have been wading through it all semester in my 371 class. In my estimation of New Criticism (at least what we do in 371, perhaps there are other methods of new criticism that are ok), you miss the forest for the trees. You are so focused on stupid little things like how the color black works throughout the story or why the word splurge comes up so frequently that you miss the big picture. New criticism has the potential to suck any and all enjoyment out of a text, which it has done without fail in 371. Literature should be enjoyed, not ripped apart and analyzed under a microscope, especially when a lot of that analysis tends to be so far fetched and unimportant. I hate it.
I think I'm a psychoanalysis maybe. It seems coincidental that my critic, Julia Kristeva, was a psychoanalyst, and my group presentation is on psychoanalysis, yet in my research I discovered, to my delight, that psychoanalysts get to look at the author and not just discard him like so many other schools of literary criticism. I like this because I still refuse to say that authorial intent has no bearing on a work. new critics will say that we don't know what an author meant, and I say bull, and then they say that we can't ask them so we don't know for sure. We as English majors are not so stupid and infantile that we need an author to come forward in an interview and say "I meant such an such when i wrote this", because if we truly know how to read a work we should be able to figure this out on our own. An author shouldnt insult our intelligence by outlining their intention in a biography. I'm not saying that we can always specifically know what an author meant all the time, but we can usually get close, and often there are several meanings, and often, God forbid, it is just meant to entertain. I would say that more often than not, the most obvious meaning of a work is the one that the author's intent. Thats all for now.
Sunday, December 7, 2008
on Don Quixote 9
I laughed out loud when Sancho was leaving to his governorship and DQ was giving him advice on how to be a good governor. DQ had just finished scolding Sancho for using proverbs in his speech so often, but then in the next paragraph he himself says, "Be moderate in sleeping, for the man who does not get up with the sun does not possess the day; and remember, Sancho, that dilligence is the mother of good fortune, and sloth, her opposite, never reached the conclusion demanded by good intentions" (734). I thought this was a perfect example of how Sancho and DQ switch roles from time to time. Another part where this happens is when Sancho is governor and he speaks very wisely when deciding cases and such. He speaks like Don Quixote sometimes, then reverts back to his old speech with a proverb every other phrase. Cervantes dose such a good job of gradually making Sancho and Don Quixote rub off on each other.
Tuesday, December 2, 2008
on 3rd round of apologies
I was in the second and there were very few people there so I don't feel the need to blog on it, those who were there know what the rest of the class missed.
Ji-won made a great point that I had never really considered before. She said how lucky we are because almost everything is translated into English. I had never thought of this but it is so true. We are completely spoiled, we have such a selection of books to read, regardless of what language they were originally written in. I began to consider some of my favorite books and they contain DQ, 100 years of solitude, love in the time of cholera, crime and punishment, and obviously the Bible. all of these are translations, and I doubt all of them are available in Korean or many other languages, yet I have access to all of them. That really surprised me to think about that, I suppose I have always just taken it for granted that so many books are translated to English.
P.s.- Ji-won speaks much better english than many of my friends, good work, bravo
Ji-won made a great point that I had never really considered before. She said how lucky we are because almost everything is translated into English. I had never thought of this but it is so true. We are completely spoiled, we have such a selection of books to read, regardless of what language they were originally written in. I began to consider some of my favorite books and they contain DQ, 100 years of solitude, love in the time of cholera, crime and punishment, and obviously the Bible. all of these are translations, and I doubt all of them are available in Korean or many other languages, yet I have access to all of them. That really surprised me to think about that, I suppose I have always just taken it for granted that so many books are translated to English.
P.s.- Ji-won speaks much better english than many of my friends, good work, bravo
on Don Quixote 8
I WILL FINISH THIS BOOK. I'm still going to blog on Don Quixote because I'm still reading it and I find it relates to just about everything, not just stuff we've talked about in class. On page 708 the Countess Trifaldi says "I have believed that from virtuous and harmonious republics poets must be banished, as Plato advised" and when I read that I was like, "WOW". It was so cool to see how something we specifically talked about in class without even mentioning its connection to DQ could come up in the book too. Tons of things went through my head-- how its almost creepy it is that some of things we've discussed in class are coming up in almost everything i read now, how it gets more and more obvious everytime i read DQ why we chose to read this book in a literary criticism class, how intertextuality is alive and well, etc. I definately agree that the second half of the book is better, but it almost might be because Im reading it with a better understanding than I did the first part. I bet if I went back and read part 1 again I would catch a lot more things.
Friday, November 28, 2008
paper
and here's my paper
Apology for Literature
In a consumer-driven world, we feel the need to constantly assign values to everything. Nothing is allowed to just stand alone as its own reward. So whether it is money, possessions, or status, the material gain you can get from something is usually what determines its value. Sancho Panza, ever the realist, subscribed to this notion by saying, “nowadays, wealth is better than wisdom: an ass covered in gold seems better than a saddled horse” (589). This idea is applied to fields of study just like everything else. Unless a major can guarantee you a high salary, your choice of job-offers and the promises of “success”, it is generally considered to be useless. English Literature happens to be one of these disparaged degrees, which forces us to constantly be defending it. Sidney wrote his apology for poetry as a defense against historians and philosophers, but today those two schools would be lumped together with Literature in the humanities. Nowadays we must defend our studies against our Engineering, Architecture, and Business counterparts. While some may find this a hard thing to do, I find it a rather simple task, given that the benefits of studying literature are so glaringly obvious to me.
For one, the study of literature teaches one how to think. It could be said that majors like math, engineering, and chemistry are basically the perfection and memorization of formulas, equations and tests. In no way is that a bad thing, but it constrains the mind in a way that prohibits creative and analytical thought. In literature there are no set rules; no equations to follow; no absolute truth or ways to prove something one way or another. Literature is not bounded by scientific reasoning. For this reason, those who study it learn to think in a way that cannot be achieved by studying the sciences or business. One must learn to think for oneself to be a Literature major. Literature students cannot follow a pattern of proofs to come to conclusions; they must use their minds to discover their own meanings. Studying literature teaches us how to think on our own, a skill that is invaluable in almost any profession, English-related or not.
Secondly, studying literature is the best way to develop decent communication skills. Articulation and proper use of language are skills whose values are limitless. What good is an idea if it cannot be properly communicated? Misunderstandings have been the downfalls of civilizations and the causes of war. Literature teaches expression and rhetoric. Without literature, we would have a 1984-style language, with words removed and the language simplified, rendering Earth a boring and expressionless place to live.
Thirdly, literature is one of the most powerful things in the world. Look at the billions of people whose religious beliefs are based on the study of a Holy Book. Look at the effect of Hitler’s propaganda. Look at Uncle Tom’s Cabin and the hastening to civil war that it brought on. Literature can persuade, direct, convince and teach when it is used properly, so it makes sense that we should study this powerful tool to understand how we can employ it in a beneficial manner.
Finally, and most importantly, literature gives insight into the human condition that no other study can. If engineering and business are the practical side of life, literature is the passionate side. Ask someone what makes life worth living, and the answer rarely settles on money or a job, but can usually be traced back to an emotion. The love of family. The joy of skiing. The pride in an accomplishment. Ask them what were the worst times of their life and once again it goes back to an emotion. The pain of death or of a break-up. Guilt from a mistake. Depression. Fear. If the heights and depths of human existence are marked by emotions, why is the one field of study that explores these emotions so often disparaged? We can read a history book and know that we declared independence in 1776, yet we can not understand the fervor and passion of patriotism without the writings of Thomas Paine and Benjamin Franklin. We are told that the Civil War was fought to end the cruelty of slavery, but cruelty is just a word until we see the suffering of the slaves through the writings of Harriet Beecher Stowe and Frederick Douglas to tell us. We know that 6 million Jews were murdered in the Holocaust, but we can’t imagine the fear they had without the writings of Anne Frank. Literature lets us understand each other; allows us to empathize with each other in a way that could not be possible with other studies.
In his Nobel Prize acceptance speech, John Steinbeck said:
The writer is delegated to declare and to celebrate man's proven capacity for greatness of heart and spirit—for gallantry in defeat, for courage, compassion and love. In the endless war against weakness and despair, these are the bright rally flags of hope and of emulation. I hold that a writer who does not believe in the perfectibility of man has no dedication, nor any membership in literature.
The study of Literature is the study of what is truly important. It can give hope. It can teach. It can create compassion. It can make us laugh. It can make us cry. It makes us understand why we do certain things. So, as long as there are humans and human emotions, literature will be necessary, and the study of it invaluable.
Apology for Literature
In a consumer-driven world, we feel the need to constantly assign values to everything. Nothing is allowed to just stand alone as its own reward. So whether it is money, possessions, or status, the material gain you can get from something is usually what determines its value. Sancho Panza, ever the realist, subscribed to this notion by saying, “nowadays, wealth is better than wisdom: an ass covered in gold seems better than a saddled horse” (589). This idea is applied to fields of study just like everything else. Unless a major can guarantee you a high salary, your choice of job-offers and the promises of “success”, it is generally considered to be useless. English Literature happens to be one of these disparaged degrees, which forces us to constantly be defending it. Sidney wrote his apology for poetry as a defense against historians and philosophers, but today those two schools would be lumped together with Literature in the humanities. Nowadays we must defend our studies against our Engineering, Architecture, and Business counterparts. While some may find this a hard thing to do, I find it a rather simple task, given that the benefits of studying literature are so glaringly obvious to me.
For one, the study of literature teaches one how to think. It could be said that majors like math, engineering, and chemistry are basically the perfection and memorization of formulas, equations and tests. In no way is that a bad thing, but it constrains the mind in a way that prohibits creative and analytical thought. In literature there are no set rules; no equations to follow; no absolute truth or ways to prove something one way or another. Literature is not bounded by scientific reasoning. For this reason, those who study it learn to think in a way that cannot be achieved by studying the sciences or business. One must learn to think for oneself to be a Literature major. Literature students cannot follow a pattern of proofs to come to conclusions; they must use their minds to discover their own meanings. Studying literature teaches us how to think on our own, a skill that is invaluable in almost any profession, English-related or not.
Secondly, studying literature is the best way to develop decent communication skills. Articulation and proper use of language are skills whose values are limitless. What good is an idea if it cannot be properly communicated? Misunderstandings have been the downfalls of civilizations and the causes of war. Literature teaches expression and rhetoric. Without literature, we would have a 1984-style language, with words removed and the language simplified, rendering Earth a boring and expressionless place to live.
Thirdly, literature is one of the most powerful things in the world. Look at the billions of people whose religious beliefs are based on the study of a Holy Book. Look at the effect of Hitler’s propaganda. Look at Uncle Tom’s Cabin and the hastening to civil war that it brought on. Literature can persuade, direct, convince and teach when it is used properly, so it makes sense that we should study this powerful tool to understand how we can employ it in a beneficial manner.
Finally, and most importantly, literature gives insight into the human condition that no other study can. If engineering and business are the practical side of life, literature is the passionate side. Ask someone what makes life worth living, and the answer rarely settles on money or a job, but can usually be traced back to an emotion. The love of family. The joy of skiing. The pride in an accomplishment. Ask them what were the worst times of their life and once again it goes back to an emotion. The pain of death or of a break-up. Guilt from a mistake. Depression. Fear. If the heights and depths of human existence are marked by emotions, why is the one field of study that explores these emotions so often disparaged? We can read a history book and know that we declared independence in 1776, yet we can not understand the fervor and passion of patriotism without the writings of Thomas Paine and Benjamin Franklin. We are told that the Civil War was fought to end the cruelty of slavery, but cruelty is just a word until we see the suffering of the slaves through the writings of Harriet Beecher Stowe and Frederick Douglas to tell us. We know that 6 million Jews were murdered in the Holocaust, but we can’t imagine the fear they had without the writings of Anne Frank. Literature lets us understand each other; allows us to empathize with each other in a way that could not be possible with other studies.
In his Nobel Prize acceptance speech, John Steinbeck said:
The writer is delegated to declare and to celebrate man's proven capacity for greatness of heart and spirit—for gallantry in defeat, for courage, compassion and love. In the endless war against weakness and despair, these are the bright rally flags of hope and of emulation. I hold that a writer who does not believe in the perfectibility of man has no dedication, nor any membership in literature.
The study of Literature is the study of what is truly important. It can give hope. It can teach. It can create compassion. It can make us laugh. It can make us cry. It makes us understand why we do certain things. So, as long as there are humans and human emotions, literature will be necessary, and the study of it invaluable.
speech
here's the speech in my class, it's slightly different than my paper and didn't touch on everything the paper did
In a consumer-driven world, we feel the need to constantly assign values to everything, usually based on material gain. Something is not worthwhile if it doesn’t lead to money, careers, possessions, or status. Obviously this applies to college as well. If a major does not guarantee multiple job offers and a high salary, it is supposedly worthless and unpractical, which is usually where literature falls. Sidney defended his poetry against historians and philosophers, but today we must defend ourselves against Engineers, Businessmen, and Architects, those “practical” majors. But I say this, if engineering and business are the practical side, then Literature is the passionate side. Ask any reasonable person what makes their life worth living, and their answer undoubtedly reverts back to an emotion. The love of family, the joy of skiing, the pride of an accomplishment. Ask them what makes their life miserable, and again the answer revolves around emotions. The pain of a death or break-up, the guilt of a mistake, depression, fear. Intangible things, not material possessions. So if the heights and depths of human existence are demarked by emotions, why are studies that deal with bridges and drain fields and math (the practical) so highly-valued, while literature is not? Literature IS emotion. History tells us that we declared independence in 1776, but we can’t understand the fervor and passion of patriotism without reading Thomas Paine and Patrick Henry. The Civil War was fought to end the cruelty of slavery, but cruelty is just a word until we see the suffering of the slaves through the writings of Harriet Beecher Stowe or Frederick Douglas. We know that 6 million Jews were murdered in the Holocaust, but we can’t imagine their fears, or their hopes, without the insight of the Diary of Anne Frank. Literature gives insight to the human condition like nothing else. It teaches us compassion. It makes us laugh. It makes us cry. It makes us understand the world around us. It gives us hope. And all of these are worth far more than a job at Boeing, or an internship at the Gap.
So, as long as there is laughter, we need literature.
As long as there is adventure, we need literature.
As long as there is suffering, we need literature.
And as long as there is love, we need literature.
In a consumer-driven world, we feel the need to constantly assign values to everything, usually based on material gain. Something is not worthwhile if it doesn’t lead to money, careers, possessions, or status. Obviously this applies to college as well. If a major does not guarantee multiple job offers and a high salary, it is supposedly worthless and unpractical, which is usually where literature falls. Sidney defended his poetry against historians and philosophers, but today we must defend ourselves against Engineers, Businessmen, and Architects, those “practical” majors. But I say this, if engineering and business are the practical side, then Literature is the passionate side. Ask any reasonable person what makes their life worth living, and their answer undoubtedly reverts back to an emotion. The love of family, the joy of skiing, the pride of an accomplishment. Ask them what makes their life miserable, and again the answer revolves around emotions. The pain of a death or break-up, the guilt of a mistake, depression, fear. Intangible things, not material possessions. So if the heights and depths of human existence are demarked by emotions, why are studies that deal with bridges and drain fields and math (the practical) so highly-valued, while literature is not? Literature IS emotion. History tells us that we declared independence in 1776, but we can’t understand the fervor and passion of patriotism without reading Thomas Paine and Patrick Henry. The Civil War was fought to end the cruelty of slavery, but cruelty is just a word until we see the suffering of the slaves through the writings of Harriet Beecher Stowe or Frederick Douglas. We know that 6 million Jews were murdered in the Holocaust, but we can’t imagine their fears, or their hopes, without the insight of the Diary of Anne Frank. Literature gives insight to the human condition like nothing else. It teaches us compassion. It makes us laugh. It makes us cry. It makes us understand the world around us. It gives us hope. And all of these are worth far more than a job at Boeing, or an internship at the Gap.
So, as long as there is laughter, we need literature.
As long as there is adventure, we need literature.
As long as there is suffering, we need literature.
And as long as there is love, we need literature.
Monday, November 24, 2008
on first round of apologies
we had the first round of apologies today and I thought overall they were pretty good. However, I think there is obviously some confusion on what an apology is and what exactly we are defending I think. I thought we had established that this is not an apology like we are sorry for something but rather that we are defending something (apologetics for anyone familiar with high school Bible classes). The presenters were right in saying that we shouldn't apologize for being English majors because there is no reason to. Most of them apologized for literature by saying that it was entertaining and that it was inspiring. That is all well, but I think someone needs to establish a concrete answer for why the study of literature (not just literature in general) is worthwhile. Why it is important to read and look at literature and why that is just as important if not more so than more "practical" field like architecture or engineering. I found even Sidney's apology didn't do this because he was defending poetry against philosphy and history, two fields now considered to be just as worthless as literature because they all fall into the humanities. I'm trying to come up with a defense that can be given to business majors or engineers because those are the type of people I find myself trying to defend myself against. I haven't totally formed it yet, but I have a few ideas, mainly relying on the fact that these other fields look at how we live our lives (careers, money, "success") while literature can teach us why we live our lives (emotions mainly). Anyone who answers the why with the answers for the how is a pathetic dolt. I find one way to explain this is that when you ask people what makes their life worth living, the answers usually can be traced back to some emotion (love of family, joy of skiing, comradery of friendship, etc.). So once it is established that non-tangible things like emotions make life worth living, doesn't it make sense then that the most valuable field of study would be the one that deals with these things? Engineering can't explain love. Business can't teach us about the joys of adventure. Architecture doesn't teach us morals. Chemistry doesn't instill compassion for those around us. Literature does all of these.
Not to sound too idealogical, but:
People are too caught up in material things. Possessions, money, "success" can all be had with a business major but we all know those things are not what are really important. If studying literature isn't important, then what is?
Not to sound too idealogical, but:
People are too caught up in material things. Possessions, money, "success" can all be had with a business major but we all know those things are not what are really important. If studying literature isn't important, then what is?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)